Gibson v. ICBC, 2010 BCSC 1097
August 16, 2010- This is a hit and run motorcycle accident case that seems to have gone sideways in part because an anonymous tip was given over the “ICBC tip line” after the Judge heard the case.
While riding his motorcycle late at night the injury claimant was struck from behind. At trial ICBC admitted fault and the claimant proved he suffered an injury to the nerve endings in his left elbow which results in numbness to the fingers in his left hand. The Court of Appeal sent the case back for a new trial because the trial judge did not give adequate reasoning for the awards.
Before the appeal was heard an anonymous tip was given over the “ICBC tip line” indicating that the accident stated by the claimant to have been a hit and run had been falsely reported. ICBC now asked the court to allow it to withdraw the admission of fault and re-argue the case. In allowing ICBC to change their position the judges stated:
“ As the Court of Appeal on the 20th of May 2008 ordered a new trial, this issue, in my view, becomes moot. Positions taken by either party at or prior to the original trial will not have any applicability at the new trial. The pleadings are as they were at the commencement of the first trial subject of course to the amendments sought. Counsel provided the authority Dawson v. Great Central Railway (1919), K.B.D. Vol. 88, 1177 at page 1181:
Swinfen Eady, M.R. — … The admission was only for the purpose of that trial; they may make another admission. It is not a question of withdrawal. On the new trial they may not make the same admission, but some other admission. They are not bound on the second trial by an admission made on the first trial for the purpose of that trial.” Posted by Mr. Renn A. Holness
Issue: Should ICBC be allowed to change the decision to admit liability based on an anonymous tip?
One responseICBC Allowed to Withdraw Their Agreement to Admit Fault
May 1, 2012 6:17am
Do not weep; do not wax indignant. Understand....
I was recommended this blog by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as no one else know such detailed about my problem. You are amazing! Thanks!...
"Renn A. Holness is a gifted lawyer and author to over 1000 legal blog articles. Married father of two daughters, son of a neurosurgeon and founder of Holness Law Group."
Jacqueline Small is diligent, professional, and compassionate. She went above and beyond when I was injured in a motor vehicle accident. Anytime I had questions she would respond quickly and always seemed to be one step ahead. I called several accident law firms and none were as knowledgeable and sincere as Jacqueline. Highly recommended!
I would totally recommend this law group. Renn handled my case with the utmost professionalism kept me informed throughout and explained in easy to understand layman's terms. I am very happy with how things worked out. I would highly recommend if you ever need a lawyer to contact him. Great job and a big thank you to all.
Over a period of 4 years Jacqueline Small guided me throughout the entirety of my personal injury claim after a motor vehicle accident left me with chronic pain. My experience was pleasant, professional, thorough, and communication was always open. I was treated with care like a person and not just a case. Jacqueline was with me every step of the way until we reached a settlement with the insurance company. 10/10 I would recommend to any friends or family.