Tierney v. GMAC Leaseco Corporation, 2010 BCSC 1179
August 24, 2010- This rather unusual “no car accident” accident involved a personal injury claimant that fell from his motorcycle when attempting to avoid another vehicle. The injury claimant foolishly set out without a helmet. The injury claimant was driving a 1983 Yamaha 750 motorcycle and was only wearing a tee shirt, shorts, and sandals. The injury claimant acknowledged that he may have been tired that evening and he had consumed alcohol. It was clear however that he was not legally impaired and the police administered an ASD test at the scene which yielded a low reading.
The court found that the absence of physical evidence, and the unreliability of the various witnesses, including hugh contradictions in the evidence, left the court with little to go on. The judge said that this is not a case where both parties are implicated and it is not possible to discern the degree to which each is responsible, leading to an equal split of fault .
The judge found that the other driver gave a straightforward story of proceeding from the highway to the curve on having made a recent right turn. She had had little opportunity to accelerate as she approached the curve. She was not preoccupied or distracted. In dismissing the injury claim the judge stated:
“I do not think it is possible to say what happened with complete confidence, although I think the defendant’s version of events more likely. What that means for the plaintiff[ injury claimant] is that he has failed to carry the burden of proof that, on a balance of probabilities, the defendant’s negligence was the cause of the accident. This means, accordingly, that the plaintiff’s action is dismissed.” Posted by Mr. Renn A. Holness
Issue: Should there have to be contact between the two vehicles for a person to make a personal injury claim with ICBC in British Columbia?
One responseMotorcylist Injuried but No Contact with the Other Vehicle- Injury Claim Dismissed
Hit and Run Injury Claimant Wins- ICBC Allegations Struck Down by Court « Holness Law Group Blog
June 14, 2011 1:50pm
[...] the time of this post still isÂ yet to be decided and you may want to take a look at my post on a motorcycle accidents in BC where there was no contact with the other vehicle. Posted by Mr. Renn A. [...]
"Renn A. Holness is a gifted lawyer and author to over 1000 legal blog articles. Married father of two daughters, son of a neurosurgeon and founder of Holness Law Group."
Jacqueline Small is diligent, professional, and compassionate. She went above and beyond when I was injured in a motor vehicle accident. Anytime I had questions she would respond quickly and always seemed to be one step ahead. I called several accident law firms and none were as knowledgeable and sincere as Jacqueline. Highly recommended!
I would totally recommend this law group. Renn handled my case with the utmost professionalism kept me informed throughout and explained in easy to understand layman's terms. I am very happy with how things worked out. I would highly recommend if you ever need a lawyer to contact him. Great job and a big thank you to all.
Over a period of 4 years Jacqueline Small guided me throughout the entirety of my personal injury claim after a motor vehicle accident left me with chronic pain. My experience was pleasant, professional, thorough, and communication was always open. I was treated with care like a person and not just a case. Jacqueline was with me every step of the way until we reached a settlement with the insurance company. 10/10 I would recommend to any friends or family.