The claimant suffered injuries as a passenger on a bus operated by the South Coast British Columbia Transportation Authority, doing business as Translink and/or Coast Mountain Bus Company Limited (“Translink”). The claimant was 76 years old at the time of trial and claims that he fell when the bus on Translink’s route number eight stopped suddenly as it travelled north on Fraser Street in East Vancouver, near 22nd Avenue (Benavides v. Doe,.2015 BCSC 1831).
Once a claimant passenger establishes that he or she was injured while riding on a public carrier, a prima facie case of negligence is made out. The onus then shifts to the defendant carrier to establish that the passenger’s injuries occurred without negligence on the part of the carrier.
The court found that the claimant established that he suffered injuries caused by the negligence of the bus driver, and that Translink was vicariously liable. The defendant Translink breached the standard of care it owed to the claimant. The claimant was found to have sustained soft tissue injuries to his neck and back, contusions to his right chest and rib cage, a strain or sprain to both hands, injury to the right side of his head and temporomandibular joint (“TMJ”), contusions to both knees and development of a large post-traumatic cyst on his right knee which required surgical removal.
Taking into account the claimants’ particular circumstances, all of the Stapley factors, including the claimant’s age, his pre-existing symptomatic arthritis and degenerative disc condition, the nature of the claimant’s injuries and their impact on his mobility and activities, and all of the authorities cited by the lawyers, the court assessed the claimant’s damages for pain and suffering and loss of amenities and enjoyment of life in the amount of $40,000.
One responseFall on Bus Results in $40,000 Award for Pain and Suffering
Bus Driver Negligent on Circumstantial Evidence | Holness Law Group
January 16, 2017 5:10am
[…] Administrator),  1 S.C.R. 424. So the trial judge misarticulated the evidentiary test ( click here to read trial decision for Benavides v. Doe) but made findings of fact sufficient to support his ultimate conclusion on liability. He was […]
"Renn A. Holness is a gifted lawyer and author to over 1000 legal blog articles. Married father of two daughters, son of a neurosurgeon and founder of Holness Law Group."
Jacqueline Small is diligent, professional, and compassionate. She went above and beyond when I was injured in a motor vehicle accident. Anytime I had questions she would respond quickly and always seemed to be one step ahead. I called several accident law firms and none were as knowledgeable and sincere as Jacqueline. Highly recommended!
I would totally recommend this law group. Renn handled my case with the utmost professionalism kept me informed throughout and explained in easy to understand layman's terms. I am very happy with how things worked out. I would highly recommend if you ever need a lawyer to contact him. Great job and a big thank you to all.
Over a period of 4 years Jacqueline Small guided me throughout the entirety of my personal injury claim after a motor vehicle accident left me with chronic pain. My experience was pleasant, professional, thorough, and communication was always open. I was treated with care like a person and not just a case. Jacqueline was with me every step of the way until we reached a settlement with the insurance company. 10/10 I would recommend to any friends or family.